I by no means thought vibrating headphones can be a good suggestion till I attempted the recently-released Razer Kraken V3 HyperSense headset. It’s a jarring idea at first — why would I need my headset to vibrate? But after spending a while with Razer’s HyperSense expertise, I’m a believer that haptic suggestions will present up in the very best gaming headsets sooner or later.
But, the idea requires perception. Although haptics have an opportunity to raise gaming, watching films, and listening to music, the choices obtainable at the moment aren’t nice — Kraken V3 HyperSense included. Here’s why haptics suggestions headphones are an incredible thought and what firms must do to make the tech higher.
Why haptic suggestions headphones make good sense
Vibrating headphones may seem to be a gimmick, however they make good sense. Sound is vibration, bodily vibration is simply sound that you simply don’t hear, and all of the locations the place you’d need haptic suggestions are the identical locations you’d hear low frequencies — particularly low bass components. If you’ve ever used a pair of headphones with a “bass boost” function, you already know this. Boosting the bass additionally vibrates the headphones.
If our headphone opinions are a mainstay for you, you possibly can skip previous this primary part. For everybody else, permit me to indulge myself. HyperSense operates inside a spread of frequencies — based mostly on a Razer chart, someplace round 20Hz to 180Hz. It’s no secret that people hear sound within the vary of 20Hz to 20kHz, with the excessive frequencies usually slipping from overexposure to loud noise or age.
High frequencies are clear; both you hear a excessive pitch otherwise you don’t. Low frequencies are imprecise. As the frequency goes decrease, the sound begins to morph from sound into feeling. Sound is simply vibration, and after a sure level, you cease listening to, and also you begin feeling.
HyperSense makes the low-end sound greater. You don’t add a subwoofer to an audio system to listen to low frequencies — you add one to really feel low frequencies. HyperSense does the identical factor in headphones. The downside is that, not like a subwoofer, HyperSense isn’t producing a spread of frequencies. It’s reacting to them, which may in the end result in a disjointed expertise. That’s precisely how haptic suggestions headphones really feel at the moment.
Expectation versus actuality
The Razer Kraken V3 HyperSense headset sells you on expectations. Immediately after listening to about haptic suggestions headphones, I conjured up pictures of bombastic bass blasts in blockbuster trailers, sounds of scraping shrapnel in AAA warfare video video games, and the thump of a thick bass guitar grooving heavy on a beat.
For transient moments whereas utilizing the headset, I skilled all of these eventualities — simply not persistently. There’s an inherent flaw with the design of HyperSense. It works based mostly on a threshold. Think about haptic suggestions in a controller; builders select when to set off the haptics, what sounds or pictures it’s reacting to and what vibration it’s making an attempt to imitate.
Massive bass blasts ship a ripple all through the headset, however so does a deep voice.
That’s not what HyperSense does. It’s taking the audio that it’s fed and spitting out suggestions based mostly on, from my testing, a slim vary of low-end frequencies. Massive bass blasts ship a ripple all through the headset, however so does a deep voice. That results in an odd disconnect the place HyperSense attracts you into an expertise earlier than pulling you instantly out of it.
After watching the Dune trailer and a compilation of the trailers from the most recent PlayStation showcase, I used to be able to shout from the rooftops that HyperSense is the best way to expertise media with headphones. After enjoying via a few of Guardians of the Galaxy and listening to Star Lord’s voice reverberate via what appeared like damaged bass port, although, I’ve a unique impression.
There’s an odd balancing act with HyperSense between what’s and what could possibly be. Although it might take a military, particular person recreation and film help might elevate HyperSense from an amusing shoo-in to an important function on any pair of over-ear headphones.
Preparing for a headache
One of the issues with HyperSense is the depth. Razer fortunately included a button on the Kraken V3 HyperSense that lets you modify the depth on the fly, however it has 4 settings: low, medium, excessive, or off. Even within the Synapse software program, you possibly can’t modify the depth manually.
The suggestions would bob forwards and backwards between being an excessive amount of and never sufficient. At its greatest, the vibration was a pleasant reassurance that immersed me in a recreation or film. At its worst, HyperSense would rock the headset midway off my ears, produce no suggestions in any respect, or give me an enormous headache.
For haptic suggestions headphones to work, you want to have the ability to modify the vibration and the sound independently on the fly. It’s a balancing act, and even after dozens of hours of utilizing the Kraken V3 HyperSense, I’d attain for a suggestions depth dial that wasn’t there.
This expertise wants a solution to filter out the junk frequencies.
Independent, granular controls are important as a result of the whole lot reacts somewhat otherwise to the haptic suggestions. Most well-produced music with a constant low-end labored nicely with the Kraken V3 HyperSense, however video video games and films have been all over. HyperSense makes a foul audio combine obvious instantly.
Beyond high quality management over the depth of the vibration, this expertise wants a solution to filter out the junk. As talked about, HyperSense operates inside a spread of frequencies, topping out someplace round 200Hz.
There are lots of junk frequencies between 100Hz and 200Hz, and I believe the disjointed feeling of HyperSense is basically resulting from this vary. Here, bass begins to sound like cardboard. It’s not low sufficient to really feel like a sub frequency, however not excessive sufficient to enterprise into the midrange. Filtering wouldn’t solely result in extra constant haptics but additionally permit customers to tune the headset for fewer complications.
Not fairly there but
HyperSense is only a idea. Although Razer now sells two headsets with the function, it’s not prepared for prime time but. If something, it’s a proof of idea. It nonetheless wants unbiased, granular controls, in addition to devoted integrations in video games and films.
Still, it’s greater than a gimmick. Razer hasn’t been shy about gimmick-y ideas — simply take a look at the ridiculous Zephyr face masks — however HyperSense is completely different. After utilizing it, I’m satisfied that haptic suggestions headphones are an idea that not practically sufficient firms are exploring. Corsair has the HS60S with haptic suggestions, however that’s it.
Hopefully, extra firms will acknowledge it as a legit function and never only a gimmick. Maybe then the expertise will get a few of the enhancements it desperately wants.